If you hold a manager accountable only for financial measures, you may increase profits in the short term, but you’re probably going to hurt the company in the long run. The focus of most public companies is necessarily short-term—i.e., making more money today. It is not uncommon to hear CEOs of public companies complain about the pressure to make poor short-term decisions in order to meet the public’s need for quarterly dividends or increasing earnings. In order to meet these constraints, some may lay off employees or cut research, training, or advertising, all of which impair the long-term success of the company.
The “balanced scorecard,” formalized by Kaplan and Norton in 1992, is a simple concept (executed in many different ways) that has at its core the goal to use a balanced set of metrics to measure the health of a business. In practicality, this means expanding management’s view beyond the financial metrics and adding other metrics to balance out the equation.
The four areas addressed in the original presentation of the balanced scorecard were:
Since then, consultants and business leaders have suggested additional measurement areas and supplied alternative titles for some of the original four areas. The balanced scorecard has evolved and adapted.
Here is one company’s approach to the balanced scorecard that emphasizes employee loyalty, and adds “competitive position” as a fifth area of measurement.
Each perspective of the balanced scorecard is further broken down for practical, day-to-day execution into the following tactical areas:
While designing a complete balanced scorecard is outside the scope of this brief introduction, I would suggest that you outline key measurement areas that tie to strategic objectives of your company and that you can continuously measure. I hope customer and employee satisfaction will be on your list. (I also strongly suggest you read through the writings of Kaplan and Norton to see the evolution of the balanced scorecard approach.)
Here are some of Mindshare’s recommendations that you should consider as you design your own balanced scorecard.
To be successful throughout your organization, the balanced scorecard must be distributed far and wide. We recommend that tailored reports of the scorecard’s core components be presented to the chairman and the unit manager, and all levels in between. Information included in the scorecard should be targeted at and relevant to each reporting unit on an individual basis.
The one area of the balanced scorecard that continues to elude many executives is arguably the single most important element to its implementation: compensation. Many executives understand the concepts of the balanced scorecard. They get fired up about getting it implemented in their company. They spend time choosing the right key metrics and measurable variables. But then, they never add the “mojo.” They never put in the “nose ring”—they never change their reward systems! Almost every company I approach tells me they use a balanced scorecard to run their business. Then I ask this simple question:
The answer all too often is... “Well, uhh, no.” (Isn’t it amazing how one simple question can clarify an issue?)
The balanced scorecard is ineffective unless your executives, your managers, your employees, and your whole company are all aligned together toward the same measurable goals. A balanced scorecard is not balanced if it measures each of the areas, but doesn’t incorporate them in compensation. It isn’t balanced if the manager’s bonus is calculated only by comparison to prior-year financials or comparison to a financial budget that was created in the dark dungeons of “corporate headquarters” months ago!
Rewards are the way for a company to put its money where its mouth is!
Another key to success for your balanced scorecard is flexibility. It is imperative that your balanced scorecard reporting system evolve along with your changing organizational needs. Your enterprise feedback management (EFM) system must be dynamic and adaptable. All too often, management expends significant effort and resources in the building of a cutting-edge program, only to see it thrown on the scrap heap a year down the road because it wasn’t built with sufficient flexibility for future growth and modification. If a solution is not flexible and dynamic, it’s not worth your time.
The balanced scorecard can be as simple or as comprehensive as you choose.
We strongly suggest starting simple and adding to your balanced scorecard over time. Mindshare EFM (see next page) can provide you with much of the data you need to establish the foundation of metrics for your balanced scorecard. Resulting metrics of customer satisfaction and employee satisfaction can be integrated with financial and/or transactional information. Mindshare will help you integrate the diverse elements of your balanced scorecard and will provide you with “best practices” guidance along the way.
All right, you’ve analyzed your business. You’ve identified the key indicators of success across the different perspectives in your company. You’ve begun to track the different metrics driving success. Now make it real. Take these high-level metrics and identify specific actions that will spur improvement in these areas. Set specific goals or targets that will enable you to monitor your progress.
The balanced scorecard will help you better align your business activities with the vision and strategy of your organization. It will provide a more accurate appraisal of where your company is headed and not just where it’s been. It will facilitate your efforts to more completely assess progress across your organization.
Remember, in order to be successful, the balanced scorecard must do these things:
Start thinking about the different key elements of your business, where they fit, and what metrics you have that measure your company’s progress. Plan ahead. Read through the books listed in the footnotes below. Consider how you can best establish the balanced scorecard as a core part of your company’s compensation program. Mindshare is here to bring best practices guidance as you define your balanced scorecard and will assist you in creating visibility at all levels across your organization.
This is how we see it.